Mar 2021

Prepare as if we already have ToBRFV

Prepare as if we already have ToBRFV

Is it only a matter of time?


Last week I was discussing the recent Tomato Brown Rugose Virus (ToBRFV) scare, the tomato industry had in December, with a colleague.  Tests carried out in Europe indicated a positive result in a small number of seeds grown in NZ.  It does appear we escaped a massive bullet as no fruit had been picked or sold, and all the plants in question were safely disposed of according to MPI.  The chance of spread was also very low risk as the further testing in NZ, to my knowledge, did not indicate a detection of the virus.

My colleague was surprised to hear that ToBRFV is not present in New Zealand.  It may be good fortune we still do not have it in NZ, but our luck could run out.  The most likely way it will come into NZ, in his opinion, is via seed importation.   The only way to minimise the risk (or at least try to) is to stay on top of all the processes.  I believe we do have strict importing processes and all of the major commercial seed companies have excellent protocols in place that follow mandatory government regulations.   Remaining vigilant and crossing the t’s and dotting the i’s is vital to keep this nasty virus out.  Commercial growers are 100% dependent on imported seed, without it we don’t have a viable industry.


Are we prepared enough if the worst happens?


If the virus does become an issue in NZ the most important step for growers is to protect themselves by having strict hygiene measures.  To be fair, many growers in New Zealand already have adequate hygiene protocols but on the other side of that coin, and to be brutally honest, some of the hygiene levels I have witnessed leave me scratching my head.  For ToBRFV water treatment (dosing), surface disinfection and fogging should be used as seperate treatments as part of hygiene protocols (in the culture and at crop rotation).


Greenhouse to Greenhouse Super Spreaders:


1: Picking crates and pallets

The unavoidable challenge is the shared crates many growers pick and pack into.  Not many growers use single use boxes or cartons, as many growers in Australia do, as an example.   Crates, if not cleaned to the guidelines for ToBRFV, make the possibility of containing an outbreak very difficult. 


2: Contract Staff

Employing contract staff for busy periods is very important and used by many companies.  I used contractors for those exact reasons and without them it would have been very difficult to efficiently run my business.  However, contract staff moving between properties pose a huge risk for any disease outbreak, including potentially spreading Bacterial Canker, which already poses a threat. 


Below is an article I have previously written with some advice, from a large supplier, on how to combat ToBRFV.   I decided to publish this article because if we become complacent then we may not be well prepared for an outbreak. 





Experience with Pepino Mosaic Virus:


While working in England, in 2007, the greenhouse company I was employed by had several greenhouses infected with Pepino Mosaic Virus (PepMV).  PepMV was a major issue at the time, in England and Europe, and could severely effect tomato crop production.  To minimise the risk of spreading PepMV to adjoining houses no one was allowed to enter a house that was infected or not infected without changing into new protective suits and gloves each time.  There was no mixing of tools, picking crates were dedicated to each individual greenhouse.  Crop workers were assigned to their own houses to limit the risk of transferring PepMV.   Crops were grown organically and conventionally on the property in soil or via substrates, the same high hygiene protocols were expected in every situation.   It was not 100% perfect but it was taken very seriously as the financial consequences were severe.



Article written by Stefan Vogrincic

All Article’s checked and edited by Marie Vogrincic

I appreciate your comments.  Please feel free to comment on the grower2grower Facebook page:



Subscribe to our E-Zine

Sign up here to subscribe to the Grower2grower Ezine. Every two weeks you will receive new articles, specific to the protected cropping industry, informing you of industry news and events straight to your inbox.


From This Category

High hygiene standards are crucial to mitigate co-infection
March 11, 2024
High hygiene standards are crucial to mitigate co-infection
No silver bullet to mitigate co-infection with the ToBRFV virus.
(Best of 2023) Hygiene a Priority in 2023
January 15, 2024
(Best of 2023) Hygiene a Priority in 2023
As plant viruses continue to cause growers headaches the best form of defence is prevention.  Crop rotation time is the best opportunity to start disease free.
Maximizing Crop Yields with Nanobubbles
November 6, 2023
Maximizing Crop Yields with Nanobubbles
Irrigation Efficiency Strategies in areas with frequent droughts and high temperatures
Extrutec’s Joe Wiid explains the connection with Polbionix and providing raw material for compostable pots.
August 28, 2023
Extrutec’s Joe Wiid explains the connection with Polbionix and providing raw material for compostable pots.
Recently at the Nursery Trade Day in Hamilton I was able to meet up with industry leaders.  One of those was Joe Wiid Managing Director of Extrutec and Peter Wilson, Founder and Director of William and Ross that have developed a biodegradable bio-based plastic - Polbionix.
Sili-Fert P plays an important role for New Zealand Growers.
July 31, 2023
Sili-Fert P plays an important role for New Zealand Growers.
Ivan Casteels, from Roam Technology, visits New Zealand for the first-time post Covid.  
June 19, 2023
“How to end the season with a spotless glasshouse”
Cleaning the greenhouse successfully at the end of the season may be critical for the success of your new planting. Check out this informative webinar from the team at Royal Brinkman.