13
Aug 2024

Up the creek without a paddle and a large hole in the canoe

Up the creek without a paddle and a large hole in the canoe
NZ – Electricity generation is BROKEN? In the end consumers will simply have to pay more for everything!

Below and email was sent to Grower2Grower by an anonymous source updating the current frailty of New Zealand’s electricity generation.  The ramifications for the greenhouse industry and those growers reliant on Natural Gas is biting hard!

Week 2 August, 2024

I’m not sure if this has made your attention at the moment, but energy prices have now officially gone mad, after the most recent period of rain didn’t make much of a dent in the hydro shortage. 

Over the last week the wholesale electricity price has effectively doubled, from averaging around 37c per kWh to now being forecast to be 74 c per kWh baseload for August.  Just this morning we saw a 150c per kWh peak.  With the electricity market at these levels, a combined cycle gas turbine (like Huntly unit 5 or TCC) can pay up to $100 per GJ, while ‘peakers’ could pay up to $150 per GJ for gas for morning peaks like this morning.

While most people I speak to are not keen on pushing the gas price to these levels, recognising that this causes lasting damage to demand, I am speaking with a number of commercial and industrial companies who are re-signing term contracts of 24-36 months with a base energy price of $30-35 per GJ (++). 

Below are the recent average daily gas and electricity prices, with little prospect that there will be relief this month.   

When Europe hit these sort of energy prices in 2022 it was global news, here its … crickets.

I’m raising this now for two reasons:

  • In case this has some bearing on your operating decisions in the short term
  • Is there a case for a rapid investigation of CHP swaps for the boilers?

If the future electricity market will continue to be highly volatile, which seems likely given renewable penetration, then perhaps going long electricity might be a good protection against gas price volatility considering the reasonably strong correlation between gas and electricity?

Something to consider.

Opinion:

The 2018 decision to ban future Natural Gas exploration – The worst political decision made in a generation?

The debate over energy sources, including the reliance on renewables versus fossil fuels, is indeed complex and multifaceted. Many people share concerns about the reliability of renewable energy, especially in regions where weather can be unpredictable. It’s important for policymakers to consider a balanced approach that ensures energy security while also addressing environmental impacts. Engaging in discussions about energy strategies can help shape future decisions that align with both economic and environmental goals.

It may, in fact be too late to overturn the damage from that ban, however, if it is a possibility, cross-party support is crucial for creating a stable and predictable environment that businesses need to make long-term investments.  Listen to https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/on-air/heather-du-plessis-allan-drive/audio/neil-holdom-new-plymouth-mayor-urges-labour-to-support-oil-and-gas-exploration/

Other related interviews:

https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/on-air/mike-hosking-breakfast/audio/john-harbord-major-electricity-users-group-chair-on-the-energy-crisis-highlighting-the-downsides-of-renewable-power/

For any comment e-mail stefan@grower2grower.co.nz

Subscribe to our E-Zine

Sign up here to subscribe to the Grower2grower Ezine. Every two weeks you will receive new articles, specific to the protected cropping industry, informing you of industry news and events straight to your inbox.

More

From This Category

2024 – The NZ greenhouse energy sector Grower2Grower report
December 3, 2024
2024 – The NZ greenhouse energy sector Grower2Grower report
Flicker of light at the end of the tunnel. What options make financial sense?
Direct Air Capture (DAC) is now a reality— Onsite CO2 generation scalable for both large and small operations
December 2, 2024
Direct Air Capture (DAC) is now a reality— Onsite CO2 generation scalable for both large and small operations
Skytree’s Camille Hanna and Ot Messemake unveil Skytree’s potential roadmap for New Zealand growers and other industrial users of food-grade CO2. The presentation showcased innovative solutions for capturing CO₂ directly from the air. Skytree offers DAC units: one powered entirely by electricity and a hybrid model that combines electricity and heat, ideal for businesses already utilizing heating or boiler systems.
Auckland plant nursery goes electric in pilot scheme
October 22, 2024
Auckland plant nursery goes electric in pilot scheme
Electric heat pump has cut its energy use by 61%
Gas supply for households and small business
October 8, 2024
Gas supply for households and small business
"This winter has highlighted the essential role natural gas plays in keeping the lights on"
Geoheat Potential of the Tauranga Geothermal System
September 9, 2024
Geoheat Potential of the Tauranga Geothermal System
The report identified that a key factor contributing to the underutilisation of available geoheat is a lack of awareness of the presence and potential of the resource
Up the creek without a paddle and a large hole in the canoe, now the canoe is patched up and has wings!
September 9, 2024
Up the creek without a paddle and a large hole in the canoe, now the canoe is patched up and has wings!
Energy prices fall substantially but is it a short-term blimp?  Is this due to the Methanex shutdowns? 
CLASSIFIED